Settling for Misconduct
skip intro
play intro
Loading...

Case 06-CV-4338

$99,999

ILLEGAL SEARCH/SEIZURE

Stop and frisk Pets Sexual harassment/abuse Stolen property Threats/intimidation Excessive force Illegal search/seizure Gun Pepper spray Drug charges Weapons charges

Plaintiff: Rene Gutierrez

Incident date: 08/22/2004

Location: 5132 S. Kolin Ave.

Allegations:

Gutierrez was sitting in his car outside his home at 51st and Kolin early one morning, planning to visit his mother-in-law, when Officers Finnigan, Pratscher, Dahlberg and Hurley drove their police car the wrong way down Kolin and blocked in Gutierrez's car. Drawing their guns, the officers got out and confronted Gutierrez, cursing at him and demanding that he get out. The officers handcuffed and searched Gutierrez and his car, without a warrant or consent. The officers didn't find any evidence of a crime, but took Gutierrez's keys, pepper-sprayed his dogs and went to enter Gutierrez's home. By this time, Negrete had been awakened by the noise and came to the door. The officers demanded to come inside, but when Negrete asked if they had a search warrant, they threw her onto the sofa and handcuffed her. Police searched both apartments in the building and found narcotics, then told Negrete she would be in trouble if she didn't tell them “where to find the money.” They also threatened to take her children and told her she could “sign papers” and avoid being arrested. Negrete told them where to find money, but refused to sign any papers without an explanation or a lawyer. The officers then cursed at her and told her she'd be going to jail. Police took $50,000 in cash and jewelry worth $45,000 from the home. Gutierrez spent about 10 days in jail before posting bond on narcotics and gun charges. Negrete spent two days in jail before posting bond on narcotics charges. All the charges were later dismissed.

Additional plaintiffs:
  • Alicia Negrete

JOHN DAHLBERG

POLICE OFFICER

1378823750
$4,324,999 total payments

JEROME FINNIGAN

POLICE OFFICER

516716974
$1,144,999 total payments

JOHN HURLEY

POLICE OFFICER

1751624935
$4,324,999 total payments

BRIAN PRATSCHER

POLICE OFFICER

1454724158
$99,999 total payments